Introduction
Buildner is excited to announce the results for the fourth edition of its Museum of Emotions Competition!
The event once again tasked participants with exploring the extent to which architecture can be used as a tool to evoke emotion. The brief called for the design of a museum comprising two exhibition halls: one designed to induce negative emotions; the other designed to induce positive emotions. Participants were free to choose any site, real or imaginary, as well as choose the scale of the project. The definition of ‘positive’ and ‘negative’ emotions was also up for interpretation: whether fear, anger, anxiety, love, happiness, how might a designer define or conceive a corresponding space?
The Museum of Emotions is one of Buildner's silent competitions, in which participants must communicate ideas using imagery void of text in any form: titles, captions, words rendered within visuals, even annotations related to scale or cardinal directions.
Buildner worked with a strong international jury panel to evaluate the received entries: Julien de Smedt is Founder of Brussels-based JDS Architects; Stephanie Deumer is a Canadian Visual Artist currently living and working in Los Angeles; Sonia Gagné is Partner at Montréal-based practice Provencher_Roy; Daniela Holt Voith is Founding Principal and Director of Design at Voith & Mactavish Architects; Lydia Kallipoliti is an architect, engineer, scholar and an Assistant Professor at the Cooper Union in New York and Principal of ANAcycle thinktank; James Krueger is Design Principal at HMC Architects’ in San Diego, California; Nuno Pimenta runs a transdisciplinary practice in Porto, with a portfolio that spans temporary architecture, installation, public art, exhibition design and performance; Italy-based architect Angelo Renna; and Lukas Rungger, Co-founder of NOA - architecture and interior design studio.
Buildner and its jury panel thank each participant for submitting to this event, which received outstanding entries from around the globe!
We sincerely thank our jury panel
for their time and expertise
Julien De Smedt
JDS Architects
Denmark
Stephanie Deumer
Visual Artist
USA
Sonia Gagné
Provencher_Roy
Canada
Daniela Holt Voith
principal and director of design, Voith & Mactavish Architects
USA
Lydia Kallipoliti
Tallin Architecture Biennale, ANAcycle thinktank
USA
James Krueger
Design Principal in HMC Architects
USA
Françoise N’Thépé
Françoise N'THEPE - Architecture & Design
France
Nuno Pimenta
NUNO PIMENTA
Portugal
Angelo Renna
Architect
Italy
Lukas Rungger
noa* network of architecture
Italy
Enter the next competition edition
Use architecture to create different emotional states
1st Prize Winner +
Buildner Sustainability Award
Buildner Sustainability Award
Open Secret
Lithuania
Jury feedback summary
The proposal depicts a mounded garbage dumping ground within a field. A deep cut through the man-made grassy hill dramatically reveals the layers of trash that form it. The newly planted hillside appears as a sort of oasis from afar, set along a meandering hiking path. Only when one accesses the quasi-monument are the rather sickening aspects of the interior revealed. The project is sophisticated in its delivery and the tension it creates between the idyllic exterior country scene and the interior experience. The project is powerful in its potential to be both immersive and educational.
This project proposes a hidden heap of trash to form a hillside with a cut to reveal its underbelly. Stairs lead down to a dark refuse enclosed room. This contrasts with a bucolic sunny scene on the surface. Beautifully rendered and carefully considered.
Daniela Holt Voith / Buildner guest jury
principal and director of design, Voith & Mactavish Architects , USA
The power of a line, minimally invasive, is exceptional in this project, which could have remained unnoticeable in lesser-able hands.
Lydia Kallipoliti / Buildner guest jury
Tallin Architecture Biennale, ANAcycle thinktank, USA
This proposal challenges conventional notions of waste disposal by envisioning landfills as dynamic and emotive public spaces. By transforming these overlooked sites into enjoyable hubs of activity and reflection, the project not only addresses the pressing issue of garbage disposal but also offers a compelling vision for the future of our urban landscapes.
Nuno Pimenta / Buildner guest jury
NUNO PIMENTA, Portugal
Buildner's commentary, recommendations and techniques review
Order your review here
The project is very successful in its hierarchy, its excellent use of color, and its advanced visuals which all clearly describe the scale of the visitor in relation to the form and scale of the site to clearly describe a unique and potent spatial experience. The use of greens and blues to depict nature stand in great contrast to the varied colors of trash to create a board that is striking. As a visual story, the more one looks, the more one can discover.
-
8/10 Linework
-
10/10 Quality of drawings
-
10/10 Balance of color
-
9/10 Layout
-
10/10 Hierarchy
-
N/A Annotation
-
N/A Text
-
9/10 Clarity of story
-
10/10 Clarity of diagrams
-
10/10 Quality of overall presentation
Enter an open architecture competition now
2nd Prize Winner +
Buildner Student Award
Buildner Student Award
How do you affect others ?
The competition provides us with an opportunity to explore and challenge various topics, pushing us beyond our comfort zones to try different types, thus fostering a continuous learning process. In competitions, we are often faced with numerous requirements and constraints, similar to those encountered in future architectural practice. However, they are also more theoretical, which stimulates our imagination and creativity. This is particularly meaningful for us as students.
Read full interview
Jury feedback summary
The project appears to be set within an urban park. In section it depicts a vast, concave excavation within a grassy field, topped by two canopies: the first, a thin shell of concrete layered in grass and peppered with rectangular openings that allow the entrance of sunlight as well as views into and out from the cavernous subterranean; the second, a set of ethereal fabrics supported on thin vertical rods which filter the sunlight and create a covered park space. The project is reminiscent of a variety of well-known projects realized in particular by Japanese architects in recent years.
I appreciate the ethereal qualities of this very simple project and particularly the floating bodies that one sees from below as a kind of spectacle. The sensations here are evoked by lived experienced and not spectacular forms.
Lydia Kallipoliti / Buildner guest jury
Tallin Architecture Biennale, ANAcycle thinktank, USA
The visualizations are very clear and easy to comprehend. The project utilizes light in a novel way, whereby the shaded areas aboveground become lighted areas below ground. My only concern is that I don't know if the glass floors would be a comfortable place for relaxing, not only physically but also psychologically, knowing that you are being watched from below.
Stephanie Deumer / Buildner guest jury
Visual Artist, USA
This is the most successful submission for me, due to the amount of thought and care given to the diagram and quality of the rendered ideas.
James Krueger / Buildner guest jury
Design Principal in HMC Architects, USA
Buildner's commentary, recommendations and techniques review
Order your review here
The section and perspectives are outstanding in their ability to describe two wholly different spaces marked by contrasting conditions of illumination and sets of materials. One can almost feel the difference in temperature and texture above versus below the contrived ‘ground line’.
-
10/10 Linework
-
10/10 Quality of drawings
-
9/10 Balance of color
-
9/10 Layout
-
10/10 Hierarchy
-
N/A Annotation
-
N/A Text
-
10/10 Clarity of story
-
10/10 Clarity of diagrams
-
10/10 Quality of overall presentation
3rd Prize Winner
Tower
China
Jury feedback summary
The proposal is for a form of tall Belvedere, stairway or tower constructed within a body of water and accessed via a lengthy raised walkway stretching linearly from a shoreline. The entire structure has a hairline thinness and the verticality of the stair is balanced by the horizontality of the walkway. One can imagine that such a crossing brings a visitor into a totally different, quiet and raw environment that contrasts with what one might find on the shore. The tower is depicted to extend below the water nearly as far as it extends skyward. Here, while the stairs are totally unnecessary, a deep dive is required to experience the darkness and marine life below the water line. The experience depends on how deep or high one might be willing to venture.
A very intriguing concept: a vertical 'promenade of emotions' spanning underwater and sky experiences. It offers a fascinating exploration of human emotions and perspectives across diverse realms.
Angelo Renna / Buildner guest jury
Architect, Italy
The images are strong and convey emotion. But I would have liked to have seen more experiential images on the journey up the stairs to better understand that space, and would expect moments of positive experiences (maybe glimpses of the view) along the path culminating in the release and full view at the top.
James Krueger / Buildner guest jury
Design Principal in HMC Architects, USA
Buildner's commentary, recommendations and techniques review
Order your review here
The project does well to balance sky with water, and verticality with horizontality. The line-based section is interesting in its scale, however, it lacks the sort of depth and variation that would bring it more meaning and detail. The sheet, as a result, appears rather unfinished and leaves one wanting to understand more about the proposition. The author would benefit from additional consideration of structure and material.
-
6/10 Linework
-
9/10 Quality of drawings
-
9/10 Balance of color
-
9/10 Layout
-
9/10 Hierarchy
-
N/A Annotation
-
N/A Text
-
8/10 Clarity of story
-
8/10 Clarity of diagrams
-
8/10 Quality of overall presentation
Honorable Mentions
Shortlisted projects
A/ENIGMA
Your Abyss
labyrinth
Sentinel of Emotions
Impressions in Impressionism
EXIT
Agoraphobia
Prejudice
Take The Stairs
How you'll take your emotions
Limbus 235
About duality
IMBRICATED
Open Secret
Surrogacy
7 BLIND MICE
The price of The Oasis
Round Rhapsody
Tower
Ambivalence of Light
Circle of Life
It's Up To You
Dissemblance
The Rock
How do you affect others ?
Time Refurbishment
Overflow of Emotions
Everflow
The living museum
The Solace Shores
The Path of Life
The allegory of liberty
Light Play
ESSENCE OF ABSENCE
Emotional Maze
Inner Quest
Being Myself
By a thread
Dear Child
